| Answer: It must be appreciated at the outset that the
prohibition of silk, and other expensive items is not directly a part of the
Sharī‘ah. In this regard, the real directives are that a believer refrain from
excessive spending and squandering of wealth as outlined by the following
verses:
Eat the fruits of these orchards when they ripen and give
away the share of Allah on the harvest day and waste not: for Allah does not
like those who spend wastefully. (6:141)
Give to the near of the kin their due and also to the
destitute and the wayfarer, and squander not in extravagance. Verily, such
squanderers are brothers of Satan and Satan is very ungrateful to His Lord.
(17:26-27)
In other words, it is very undesirable that a person
instead of spending in the way of Allah and adopting a balanced attitude towards
his needs and desires, spends lavishly and wastefully. Islam wants that a person
remain sensitive to the needs of his religion and to the needs of the deprived.
If he has been blessed with wealth, he should always be looking for
opportunities to spend in the way of Allah. For he must remember that the wealth
he has is a sacred trust of the Almighty. He has become its beneficiary not
because it was his right, but because he has been put through a trial and test
by the Almighty. Islam also wants that a Muslim’s real interest be the life of
the Hereafter. He should benefit from the pleasures and delights of this world
to certain extent only. One motive of spending lavishly and squandering wealth
is pomp and show, and one must remember that pomp and show tarnish the mirror of
one’s soul. Over indulgence makes a person unmindful of the Hereafter, and a
person who becomes unmindful of this great reality is a person who is bound to
doom.
Consequently, while explaining these divine directives,
the Prophet (sws) is reported to have said:
Eat, drink and spend in the way of Allah and clothe
yourself, guarding against wastefulness and vanity. (Ibn Mājah, Kitāb al-Libās)
He who wore a dress for show and fame in this world, the
Almighty shall make him wear the dress of ignominy in the Hereafter and then
ignite fire in it. (Ibn Mājah, Kitāb al-Libās)
While applying these divine directives, the Prophet (sws)
forbade certain things which came under them. About wearing silk he said:
He who wore silk in this world shall never wear it in the
Hereafter. (Bukhārī, Kitāb al-Libās)
One must appreciate that as a principle, all directives of
the Prophet (sws) which are based on the application of a divine directive are
valid as long as the underlying reason which became the basis of this
application holds good in changed circumstances. In other words, if today silk
is still considered to be an expensive cloth and a symbol of pomp and show, then
a person should refrain from wearing it for the reasons stated, and, if it does
not bear this label, a person can wear it. It is for him to decide. If he is of
the opinion that wearing silk whether as a cloth or in the form of a tie is not
right, then it is only befitting for him to follow what he believes.
If you are convinced about not wearing silk, and also
think that the adverse consequences of not wearing it create more imbalances
than you can handle then you can continue with a heavy heart but with a firm
resolve to come out of this situation as soon as possible. The Almighty never
demands of a person what is beyond him. If he has a legitimate plea, the
Almighty will certainly entertain it. However, no external agency should give a
verdict in this regard. The decision is yours, since it is you who will have to
justify it before Allah on the Day of Judgement. |